All-NFC Teams: 2000s | 2010s | 2020s
| 1992 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Steve Young | SF | DE | Chris Doleman | MIN | PK | Morten Andersen | NO |
| RB | Barry Sanders | DET | DE | Reggie White | PHI | P | Rich Camarillo | PHX |
| RB | Emmitt Smith | DAL | DT | Pierce Holt | SF | KR | Deion Sanders | ATL |
| WR | Jerry Rice | SF | DT | Henry Thomas | MIN | PR | Kelvin Martin | DAL |
| WR | Sterling Sharpe | GB | OLB | Rickey Jackson | NO | ST | Elbert Shelley | ATL |
| TE | Jay Novacek | DAL | OLB | Wilber Marshall | WAS | | | |
| C | Mark Stepnoski | DAL | ILB | Byron Evans | PHI | | | |
| G | Randall McDaniel | MIN | ILB | Sam Mills | NO | | | |
| G | Guy McIntyre | SF | CB | Audray McMillian | MIN | | | |
| T | Harris Barton | SF | CB | Ricky Reynolds | TB | | | |
| T | Steve Wallace | SF | S | Chuck Cecil | GB | | | |
| | | S | Tim McDonald | PHX | | | |
| 1993 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Steve Young | SF | DE | Richard Dent | CHI | PK | Norm Johnson | ATL |
| RB | Jerome Bettis | LARams | DE | Reggie White | GB | P | Rich Camarillo | PHX |
| RB | Emmitt Smith | DAL | DT | Sean Gilbert | LARam | KR | Tyrone Hughes | NO |
| WR | Jerry Rice | SF | DT | John Randle | MIN | PR | Tyrone Hughes | NO |
| WR | Sterling Sharpe | GB | OLB | Rickey Jackson | NO | ST | Elbert Shelley | ATL |
| TE | Brent Jones | SF | OLB | Seth Joyner | PHI | | | |
| C | Mark Stepnoski | DAL | ILB | Michael Brooks | NYG | | | |
| G | Randall McDaniel | MIN | ILB | Hardy Nickerson | TB | | | |
| G | Nate Newton | DAL | CB | Eric Allen | PHI | | | |
| T | Harris Barton | SF | CB | Deion Sanders | ATL | | | |
| T | Erik Williams | DAL | S | LeRoy Butler | GB | | | |
| | | S | Tim McDonald | SF | | | |
| 1994 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Steve Young | SF | DE | Charles Haley | DAL | PK | Fuad Reveiz | MIN |
| RB | Barry Sanders | DET | DE | Reggie White | GB | P | Reggie Roby | WAS |
| RB | Emmitt Smith | DAL | DT | John Randle | MIN | KR | Mel Gray | DET |
| WR | Cris Carter | MIN | DT | Dana Stubblefield | SF | PR | Brian Mitchell | WAS |
| WR | Jerry Rice | SF | OLB | Ken Harvey | WAS | ST | Maurice Douglass | CHI |
| TE | Brent Jones | SF | OLB | Bryce Paup | GB | | | |
| C | Kevin Glover | DET | ILB | Jack Del Rio | MIN | | | |
| G | Randall McDaniel | MIN | ILB | Chris Spielman | DET | | | |
| G | Nate Newton | DAL | CB | Deion Sanders | SF | | | |
| T | Lomas Brown | DET | CB | Donnell Woolford | CHI | | | |
| T | Willie Roaf | NO | S | Merton Hanks | SF | | | |
| | | S | Darren Woodson | DAL | | | |
| 1995 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Brett Favre | GB | DE | William Fuller | PHI | PK | Morten Andersen | ATL |
| RB | Barry Sanders | DET | DE | Reggie White | GB | P | Jeff Feagles | ARI |
| RB | Emmitt Smith | DAL | DT | John Randle | MIN | KR | Brian Mitchell | WAS |
| WR | Herman Moore | DET | DT | Dana Stubblefield | SF | PR | Brian Mitchell | WAS |
| WR | Jerry Rice | SF | OLB | Ken Harvey | WAS | ST | Elbert Shelley | ATL |
| TE | Mark Chmura | GB | OLB | William Thomas | PHI | | | |
| C | Kevin Glover | DET | MLB | Ken Norton Jr. | SF | | | |
| G | Larry Allen | DAL | CB | Eric Davis | SF | | | |
| G | Randall McDaniel | MIN | CB | Aeneas Williams | ARI | | | |
| T | Lomas Brown | DET | S | Merton Hanks | SF | | | |
| T | Willie Roaf | NO | S | Darren Woodson | DAL | | | |
| 1996 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Brett Favre | GB | DE | Tony Tolbert | DAL | PK | John Kasay | CAR |
| RB | Terry Allen | WAS | DE | Reggie White | GB | P | Matt Turk | WAS |
| RB | Barry Sanders | DET | DT | John Randle | MIN | KR | Michael Bates | CAR |
| WR | Herman Moore | DET | DT | Bryant Young | SF | PR | Desmond Howard | GB |
| WR | Jerry Rice | SF | OLB | Kevin Greene | CAR | ST | Jim Schwantz | DAL |
| TE | Wesley Walls | CAR | OLB | Lamar Lathon | CAR | | | |
| C | Kevin Glover | DET | MLB | Sam Mills | CAR | | | |
| G | Larry Allen | DAL | CB | Aeneas Williams | ARZ | | | |
| G | Randall McDaniel | MIN | CB | Deion Sanders | DAL | | | |
| T | Lomas Brown | ARI | S | LeRoy Butler | GB | | | |
| T | Willie Roaf | NO | S | Darren Woodson | DAL | | | |
| 1997 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Brett Favre | GB | DE | Michael Strahan | NYG | PK | Jason Hanson | DET |
| RB | Dorsey Levens | GB | DE | Robert Porcher
Chuck Smith | DET
ATL | P | Matt Turk | WAS |
| RB | Barry Sanders | DET | DT | John Randle | MIN | KR | Michael Bates | CAR |
| WR | Herman Moore | DET | DT | Dana Stubblefield | SF | PR | David Palmer | MIN |
| WR | Rob Moore | ARI | OLB | Jesse Armstead | NYG | ST | Travis Jervey | GB |
| TE | Wesley Walls | CAR | OLB | Derrick Brooks | TB | | | |
| C | Kevin Glover | DET | MLB | Hardy Nickerson | TB | | | |
| G | Larry Allen | DAL | CB | Aeneas Williams | ARI | | | |
| G | Randall McDaniel | MIN | CB | Deion Sanders | DAL | | | |
| T | Willie Roaf | NO | S | LeRoy Butler | GB | | | |
| T | Todd Steussie | MIN | S | Merton Hanks | SF | | | |
| 1998 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Randall Cunningham | MIN | DE | Michael Strahan | NYG | PK | Gary Anderson | MIN |
| RB | Jamal Anderson | ATL | DE | Reggie White | GB | P | Matt Turk | WAS |
| RB | Garrison Hearst | SF | DT | John Randle | MIN | KR | Roell Preston | GB |
| WR | Antonio Freeman | GB | DT | Warren Sapp | TB | PR | Deion Sanders | DAL |
| WR | Randy Moss | MIN | OLB | Jesse Armstead | NYG | ST | Michael Bates | CAR |
| TE | Mark Chmura | GB | OLB | Derrick Brooks | TB | | | |
| C | Jeff Christy | MIN | MLB | Jessie Tuggle | ATL | | | |
| G | Kevin Gogan | SF | CB | Ray Buchanan | ATL | | | |
| G | Randall McDaniel | MIN | CB | Deion Sanders | DAL | | | |
| T | Larry Allen | DAL | S | LeRoy Butler | GB | | | |
| T | Todd Steussie | MIN | S | Eugene Robinson | ATL | | | |
| 1999 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Kurt Warner | STL | DE | Kevin Carter | STL | PK | Jason Hanson | DET |
| RB | Stephen Davis | WAS | DE | Robert Porcher | DET | P | Mitch Berger | MIN |
| RB | Marshall Faulk | STL | DT | Luther Elliss | DET | KR | Tony Horne | STL |
| WR | Isaac Bruce | STL | DT | Warren Sapp | TB | PR | Glyn Milburn | CHI |
| WR | Cris Carter | MIN | OLB | Jesse Armstead | NYG | ST | Michael Bates | CAR |
| TE | Wesley Walls | CAR | OLB | Derrick Brooks | TB | | | |
| C | Jeff Christy | MIN | MLB | Hardy Nickerson | TB | | | |
| G | Larry Allen | DAL | CB | Todd Lyght | STL | | | |
| G | Tre Johnson | WAS | CB | Deion Sanders | DAL | | | |
| T | Orlando Pace | STL | S | Brian Dawkins | PHI | | | |
| T | Willie Roaf | NO | S | John Lynch | TB | | | |
The PFWA’s All-NFL teams were presented in conjunction with Pro Football Weekly from 1992-2012.
Many thanks to John Turney of the Professional Football Researchers Association for his assistance in completing the PFWA’s award history.