All-AFC Teams: 1990s | 2000s | 2010s
| Offense | Defense | Special Teams | ||||||
| QB | Patrick Mahomes | KC | DE | Joey Bosa | LAC | PK | Justin Tucker | BAL |
| RB | Nick Chubb | CLE | DE | Myles Garrett | CLE | P | Jake Bailey | NE |
| RB | Derrick Henry | TEN | DT | DeForest Buckner | IND | KR | Andre Roberts | NUF |
| WR | Stefon Diggs | BUF | DT | Chris Jones | KC | PR | Gunner Olszewski | NE |
| WR | Tyreek Hill | KC | OLB | Bradley Chubb | DEN | ST | George Odum | IND |
| TE | Travis Kelce | KC | OLB | T.J. Watt | PIT | |||
| C | Ryan Kelly | IND | MLB | Darius Leonard | IND | |||
| G | Joel Bitonio | CLE | CB | Xavien Howard | MIA | |||
| G | Quenton Nelson | IND | CB | Tre’Davious White | BUF | |||
| T | Garrett Bolles | DEN | S | Minkah Fitzpatrick | PIT | |||
| T | Jack Conklin | CLE | S | Tyrann Mathieu | KC | |||