All-Rookie Teams: 1970s | 1980s | 1990s | 2000s | 2010s
| Offense | Defense | Special Teams | ||||||
| QB | Justin Herbert | LAC | DL | Derrick Brown | CAR | PK | Rodrigo Blankenship | IND |
| RB | James Robinson | JAX | DL | Raekwon Davis | MIA | P | Tommy Townsend | KC |
| RB | Jonathan Taylor | IND | DL | Javon Kinlaw | SF | KR | Tommy Townsend | IND |
| WR | Chase Claypool | PIT | DL | Chase Young | WAS | PR | James Proche II | BAL |
| WR | Justin Jefferson | MIN | LB | Kenneth Murray Jr. | LAC | ST | Jordan Glasgow | IND |
| TE | Harrison Bryant | CLE | LB | Patrick Queen | BAL | |||
| C | Lloyd Cushenberry III | DEN | LB | Isaiah Simmons | ARI | |||
| G | Damien Lewis | SEA | CB | Cameron Dantzler | MIN | |||
| G | Mike Onwenu | NE | CB | L’Jarius Sneed | KC | |||
| T | Jedrick Wills Jr. | CLE | S | Jeremy Chinn | CAR | |||
| T | Tristan Wirfs | TB | S | Antoine Winfield Jr. | TB | |||